When it comes to psychological horror with a supernatural twist, Longlegs stands in a league of its own. It’s a film where every character matters, each one adding a layer to the mystery, madness, and malevolence that unfolds. From haunted investigators to devilish figures cloaked in shadows, Longlegs is packed with memorable, eerie, and downright disturbing personalities that leave a lasting impression. Whether they’re delivering spine-chilling dialogue or staring you down with unsettling calm, these characters are impossible to forget.
So, who stood out the most? Which figures burrowed into your brain and refused to leave? 😵💫🖤 In this list, we’re counting down the Top 5 Best Characters in Longlegs—from the enigmatic to the terrifying, the quietly tragic to the full-blown demonic. These aren’t just “good” characters—they’re the ones that make Longlegs such a haunting and unforgettable experience. Ready to dive into the dark? Let’s get creepy. 😈
5. Agent Carter – The Grounded Soul in a Twisted World
Blair Underwood steps into the role of Agent Carter, the “normal guy” amidst a world filled with chaos, madness, and deeply disturbing backstories. While most characters in Longlegs feel like they crawled out of a nightmare, Carter stands tall as the voice of logic and reason—a loving husband, a caring father, and a man grounded in reality.
But that’s exactly why his presence hurts the most. 💔 Watching his world collapse by the film’s end is gut-wrenching, especially because he’s the most human character in the entire story. Sure, he doesn’t have a standout personality or flashy traits—if anything, he feels like a character you’d find in Criminal Minds or CSI. And that’s not a diss! It means he served his purpose with quiet strength and subtle emotion. He’s not the flashiest, but he’s essential—and for that, he earns the 5th spot on my Longlegs characters list. 👏
4. Carrie Anne – A Survivor Twisted by Terror
Do you remember the crazy girl with the short hair who survived her encounter with Longlegs? That’s Carrie Anne, brought to life brilliantly by Kiernan Shipka. Despite having just a few minutes of screen time, she steals the spotlight with one of the scariest dialogues in the entire film. When left alone with Lee Harker, Carrie Anne unleashes a side of herself that’s not only wicked and intimidating, but also deeply unsettling—and somehow, we totally understand her.
You see, Carrie Anne isn’t just some random lunatic. She’s a survivor—one broken and twisted by trauma, molded by fear. So when she threatens Lee Harker and praises Longlegs like a prophet might a god, it doesn’t come off as nonsense. It’s logical from her fractured perspective. Kiernan’s eerie delivery, coupled with her slouched yet strangely alluring body language, makes every gesture and word hit like a thunderbolt ⚡. In just a few lines, she turns Carrie Anne into a haunting symbol of how deeply Longlegs can corrupt a soul. Honestly? I would’ve loved to see a lot more of her. 😵💫👏
3. Ruth Harker – The Mother of All Nightmares
From the very first phone call between Lee Harker and her mother, Ruth Harker, you could feel something was off. There was a strange, suffocating energy to it—a twisted, invisible thread connecting them. And oh boy, did it unravel beautifully. Ruth isn’t just some side character or ominous presence—she’s basically the film’s secondary villain, and ironically, the one Lee must literally face in the end to conquer her past. That final confrontation? Chilling. Powerful. Symbolic. It makes Ruth’s role one of the most vital in the entire film.
Now let’s give flowers where they’re due—Alicia Witt deserves massive praise 🌹👏. She delivers a performance that’s both hauntingly tender and creepily unhinged, balancing the facade of a caring mother with the cold, calculating darkness of a devoted villain. Her line delivery, expressions, and general demeanor all scream “danger,” yet you can’t look away. Ruth Harker is a masterpiece of horror character writing, and Alicia brings her to terrifying life. She could’ve easily been #1, but for now, she reigns proudly at #3 on this list—and she absolutely earned it. 🩸✨
PS. That pose with her hands in the air, as she’s covered in blood, saying “Heil Satan“. Yes. That will go down in history as one of the most scary, and yet badass, moments in Horror!
2. Lee Harker – The Traumatized Heroine Who Steals the Show
First things first, let’s give a massive round of applause to Maika Monroe—she’s without a doubt one of the best Scream Queens in the business today. Once again, she proves herself as a powerhouse actress in Longlegs, taking on a role unlike anything we’ve ever seen from her. If you’ve watched the movie, you already know exactly what I’m talking about. Maika nails it, and Lee Harker is a testament to her incredible range.
Now, Lee Harker is a character that’s both relatable and deeply tragic. She’s the kind of person who feels a bit “off” when compared to the world around her—someone who feels different, perhaps even a little out of place, but isn’t that what makes her so endearing? Whether it’s her shy, kind-hearted nature or her inability to exist outside the confines of her job, you just want to wrap your arms around her.
Lee is a mess in the most human way possible, struggling to exist outside of her work, but that’s what makes her feel so real. Maika delivers an emotional depth that is both heartbreaking and stunning, especially in her interactions with Carrie Anne and Longlegs. Those scenes become even more gripping thanks to her ability to sell raw emotion. She makes the creepy villainous characters that much scarier.
Lee might just be one of the MVPs of this film, and although I could see her taking the #1 spot, I’m personally placing her at #2. Still, she’s an absolute standout. 👏💀
1. Longlegs: Nicolas Cage Becomes the Devil’s Mouthpiece in Longlegs – A Supernatural Villain for the Ages
Nicolas Cage delivers a performance so haunting, so electrifying, that it feels destined to be studied by film students and revered by horror fans for generations. It’s no small feat—buried beneath layers of heavy makeup and eerie prosthetics, he still commands the screen with chilling precision. In Longlegs, you don’t see Nic Cage—you see him. The unsettling “cuckooooo,” the off-kilter singing, the piercing presence that crawls under your skin… it’s not just a performance; it’s a transformation—one that lingers long after the credits roll. And honestly? That’s worthy of a standing ovation. 👏
Now, let’s be clear—Longlegs is no ordinary villain. He’s not just a man… he’s an entity. Something more. Something beyond. His powers transcend logic, hinting at an unholy bond with “the man downstairs”—yes, the devil himself. 🕯️😈 That black magic coursing through his veins is what gives him that unshakable, almost immortal presence.
Whether he’s casually chatting with a child in a store or staring down Lee Harker in an interrogation room, Longlegs is always in control. That eerie calm, the supernatural power, the sense that you can’t win. Those things, and so much more is what makes him one of the most memorable horror villains in years. 😈
Longlegs – The Undeniable Master of Horror 👑👹
And there you have it—the King of Longlegs has rightfully earned the #1 spot on this list. It’s no surprise, really, when you’ve got a character as haunting and electric as Longlegs, played with uncanny brilliance by Nicolas Cage. He dominates the screen, leaving a chilling presence that lingers long after the credits roll. There’s just something about this twisted villain that makes him stand out from the rest. Whether it’s his eerie voice, his otherworldly powers, or that almost immortal vibe he gives off. And with that said, he’s the best of the best characters in Longlegs! 👏👀
